Last Friday, the Tsukiji Market held its final auction. The 83-year-old exchange and major Tokyo tourist attraction is moving to a new waterfront location in Toyosu. Soon, the Tsukiji Market will be gone.
Nobody seemed to tell the throng of tourists flooding out of Tsukiji Station earlier this morning. With the auctions over, I wondered if people would still come.
The outer market at Tsukiji. (Photo: Brian Ashcraft/Kotaku)
For now, yes.
The outer market was bustling, jam-packed with people eating, shopping and taking photos. When the fish market relocates, the outer market will stay behind.
Even without the fish auctions, the outer market offers an array of shopping and eating experiences that are increasingly dwindling in Japan with the proliferation of shopping malls and supermarket chains.
An outer market food stall. (Photo: Brian Ashcraft/Kotaku)
An outer market vendor selling Japanese pickles. (Photo: Brian Ashcraft/Kotaku)
An outer market stall selling dried fish products. (Photo: Brian Ashcraft/Kotaku)
But I wanted to go to the inner market one last time before it closes on 29 September. This is where the Tsukiji workers eat their meals and buy necessities like rubber boots. Some of this stalls and restaurants will move to the new location. Some will close forever.
The Tsukiji Market opened in 1935. Parts look like they haven’t been renovated since. It was originally built as a replacement for the Nihonbashi Market, which was damaged badly during the Great Kanto Earthquake of 1923.
Over the past three decades, the number of fish vendors and sellers at Tsukiji has dropped by nearly half. In the Nikkei, former Tsukiji fish trader Naoto Nakamura explains that fisherman are now apparently selling their best fish to supermarkets, who can guarantee better prices. According to Nakamura, that means the fish that ends up at Tsukiji have been the second-raters.
While there are fewer fish traders, the number of tourists has skyrocketed. Japan continues to set records for foreign visitors. High on the lists of tourists is Tsukiji. It’s been a blessing and a curse.
“Tourists kept getting in the way,” a vendor in the inner market explains to two middle-aged women. “They weren’t there to buy fish, but just take photos and some of them were touching the fish.”
Flyer posted in the inner market. (Photo: Brian Ashcraft/Kotaku)
The word the sake vendor used was “jama” (邪魔), which literally means “obstacle,” “hindrance” or “disturbance.” Typically, Japanese people do as much as they can to get out of the way of others, but even if you are attempting to do likewise at Tsukiji, it’s so crowded that you cannot help by feel like you’re getting in someone’s way. Tsukiji workers, for the most part, handle the situation with aplomb. Unless you are touching the fish, which is inexcusable, or generally being a jerk.
The decision to move the market is controversial. As Nikkei reports, there had been discussions since the 1950s, but apparently, it wasn’t until 1999 that former Tokyo governor Shintaro Ishihara made the call. It’s been delayed repeatedly, most recently for contamination concerns at the new site.
Toyosu was previously the home of a gas plant. Since then, arsenic and benzene have been reportedly found at the location, which is concerning. “Many environmental scientists said it was impossible to clean up this contamination, but the Tokyo government overrode their concerns, claiming that the surface soil had been cleared of contamination and that a series of 55 wells and pumps had lowered underground water levels,” wrote Nakamura in the Nikkei. “This, it is said, will prevent recontamination, helped by a layer of impervious earth under the site.”
“It’s going to be really different at the new location,” I said to the woman sitting next to me at Senri-ken, an inner market coffee shop. I was planning on eating sushi today, as that seemed to be the logical decision, but walking around the market was like taking a trip through time. The signs, the letter and fonts reeked of styles popular during the first half of the Showa Period (1926-1989).
Photo: Brian Ashcraft (Kotaku)
I started feeling nostalgic and wanted to eat Showa-style food and headed over to Senri-ken. It’s where many fish traders eat breakfast.
There was no line, but inside the place was packed. I ordered cream stew, toast, salad and coffee. I break open the poached egg in the cream stew and mix in the runny yolk. I take a bite of the stew. It’s warm and comforting. The coffee is excellent, too.
“Yeah, the new location will be different,” the woman next to me says. “It won’t have this ambience.”
I look up above the coffee pot. Years of steam have caused the lacquer above the counter to peel, revealing the grain underneath. Metal cabinets no longer gleam and flames flicker through the tiny slots in the gas heater. It’s cramped but comfortable and welcoming. The coffee shop has decades worth of character. All that will be lost.
I finish up my coffee and sit at the counter for a moment, before paying and leaving.
When I first came to Japan seventeen years ago, there were more old Showa-style places like this in Osaka and Tokyo. Years and years ago when these cafes and restaurants opened, they were shiny and contemporary, most likely replacing what had existed before. I don’t begrudge the lost of these retro establishments, because that’s the nature of things.
A contemporary building towers over the inner market’s outskirts. (Photo: Brian Ashcraft/Kotaku)
Something else takes their place and perhaps decades from now, future generations will have similar nostalgia.
The Toyosu Market will open on 11 October.
The new location won’t give visitors an inside look at the auction. Instead, visitors will watch the action from behind glass. While that might be a shame for tourists, I can understand why it’s necessary to make the change. As Tokyo Cheapo also explains, the new fish market won’t charge admission, but visitors can no longer purchase fish directly from the vendors. Instead, you’ll have to buy from the approved food stalls.
T-shirt vendor in the outer market. (Photo: Brian Ashcraft/Kotaku)
No doubt, it will be a different experience. But I feel like even more than that will be lost.
Header photo: Brian Ashcraft (Kotaku)