Musicians' Union Protests Zelda Concert

By Stephen Totilo on at

A 90-piece Zelda symphony held in New York this week drew fans but also a protest in the form of a musicians union and a large inflatable rat.

Local 802, the Associated Musicians of Greater New York, objected to the Tuesday-evening symphony using non-union players. John O’Connor, a vice president for the union, who was standing by the big rat last night told Kotaku that he believed that the group putting on the show, Massimo Gallotta Productions, was using young musicians from out of state and paying them at a lower rate without union benefits.

Musicians' Union Protests Zelda Concert

The rat is a common sight in metropolitan areas like New York City, where unions will inflate it to draw attention to projects they say flout union standards or concerns. It's erected near construction sites and concerts held in arenas that hosts big concerts, and the like.

Fans wearing Zelda shirts and humming Zelda tunes made the 802’s position clear:

Musicians' Union Protests Zelda Concert

The concert’s promoter, Massimo Gallotta, told Kotaku he was surprised that the union protested. “It was so out of the blue,” he said, adding that the performance had been announced months ago but the union had only contacted him last week. “I’m doing the whole tour in US, Europe and Canada, and we didn’t have any problems so far. Just New York. The reason I didn’t get union musicians is because the Barclays Center is a non-union building; we don’t have to get union musicians.” For this show he said he used players from Boston as well as local non-union musicians from New York.

A Nintendo rep did not reply to a request for comment.

O’Connor said that the Zelda musicians were being paid on the cheap, earning $100 less for the show than they would have with the union and receiving no benefits. Gallotta denied that figure and said their contracts were “reasonable”. Though he cited the expenses of running shows in New York, he adds that the reason he used non-union musicians wasn’t due to costs. “For us it is an artistic choice first.”

Gallotta said he has used union musicians in cities and venues that require it, including for last night’s Zelda music performance on The Late Show With Stephen Colbert:

The fact that Gallotta used union players at one performance with Colbert last night and not at Barclays is exactly what frustrated O’Connor’s union. Asked if he knew if this was a one-time thing, O’Connor replied, “I sure hope so.”

Gallotta said last night’s Zelda concert was a success aside from the union protest and that he hopes to bring the tour back to New York. He wasn’t sure what the venue would be.